The Hulls of Sailboats

Sailboats with auxiliary engines all have displacement hulls. Only a few rare examples, such as the MacGregor 36 (shown in the illustration of this article), are equipped with planing hulls. But does this common characteristic among sailboats give them identical features?No, not at all. They differ significantly in their appendages, particularly their keels.

‍

Published on
September 11, 2024

A. What is the purpose of a sailboat’s keel?

The keel of a sailboat serves several essential functions. On a ballasted sailboat, the keel contributes to stability and the righting moment, while also providing lateral resistance to reduce leeway.

‍

Righting Moment

The Righting Moment (GZ)

The keel plays a crucial role in the sailboat's righting moment.

The ballast lowers the boat's centre of gravity, helping to counteract the heeling moment generated by the wind on the sails. Capsizing can occur when the heeling moment exceeds the boat's available righting moment and stability can no longer be maintained.

The righting moment depends on the vessel's displacement and the righting arm (GZ), which is the horizontal distance between the lines of action of buoyancy and weight when the boat is heeled.

For this reason, racing sailboats often have deep keels with lead ballast positioned as low as possible to maximise the righting moment. Lead is approximately 45% denser than steel.

The greater the sail-carrying power of a boat, the greater the righting moment it generally needs. This can be achieved through ballast weight, keel depth, hull form and other design features.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

The Lateral Resistance Plane

‍

Sailboats experience lateral forces from the wind that can cause leeway.

When sailing, the wind generates a lateral force that causes varying amounts of leeway depending on the point of sail, affecting the boat's course through the water. To reduce leeway, sailboats rely on the lateral resistance provided by their underwater hull and appendages. Lateral resistance is provided by the keel, centreboard, daggerboard, rudder and/or underwater hull surfaces, depending on the vessel's design.

These underwater surfaces generate hydrodynamic side force that counteracts the lateral force produced by the sails.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

B. Types of Keels

‍

1. Full Keel: Directional Stability

‍

Until the late 1970s, many cruising sailboats were equipped with full-length keels. This type of keel, often integrated into the hull structure, provided excellent directional stability.

The full keel provided a large lateral resistance area, contributing significantly to the boat's directional stability. Thanks to their directional stability, these boats could often maintain a steady course with the helm lashed in position. Particularly directionally stable when sailing downwind, these boats were less prone to yawing. However, their long keels made manoeuvring under engine power, especially in reverse, more difficult and sometimes unpredictable.

‍
On some full-keel designs, the propeller was housed in an aperture near the aft end of the keel, providing some protection against grounding. Full-length keels became less common as hull designs evolved towards wider, flatter aft sections and separate fin keels, offering improved manoeuvrability and performance.

‍

A Stratimer Endurance 37, designed by Peter Ibold, featuring a long keel and skeg.

Advantages:

Improved directional stability

  • Robust construction, good grounding resistance and the ability to take the ground in suitable conditions
  • Propeller protection within the keel aperture

‍

Disadvantages:

  • Reduced manoeuvrability under engine power, particularly when reversing
  • Slower response to significant course changes

‍

‍

‍

‍

2. Fin Keel: The Modern Keel

‍

The Encapsulated Keel of a Contessa 35

Fin keels have largely replaced traditional full-length keels on modern sailing yachts. Several types of fin keel can be distinguished according to their construction and ballast arrangement.

Early fin-keel designs often featured encapsulated ballast. The keel structure is moulded as part of the hull, with the ballast enclosed within the composite laminate. These keels can be extremely robust, but their construction requires considerable care and time.

‍

‍

‍
Erik Aanderaa's Contessa 35, Tessie, features an encapsulated keel. The Norwegian sailor is known for his demanding offshore voyages in challenging weather conditions. Is this a coincidence? Probably not! However, not all fin keels are encapsulated. Externally bolted fin keels subsequently became widespread.

‍
These keels are attached to the hull using keel bolts, with construction methods varying between manufacturers. These keels are often made from a single cast-iron casting, which is protected with coatings and secured to the hull using keel bolts.

Depending on the boat's design and manufacturer, the keel may be secured using several threaded keel bolts or studs. The threaded studs may be cast into the keel or secured using captive nuts recessed into the keel structure.

‍

‍

Inside the hull, the keel studs pass through the hull structure and are secured with nuts and backing plates. Two main construction methods are commonly used. Many modern sailing yachts feature a composite hull moulded as a single structure, sometimes using resin infusion. The hull laminate thickness varies depending on the design and the structural loads involved.

‍
Longitudinal stringers and transverse floors are manufactured separately and then laminated or bonded to the hull. The keel bolts pass through a reinforced structural framework designed to distribute keel loads throughout the hull.

‍

‍

‍

‍

Keel Bolts Secured Through Reinforcements Laminated to the Hull

Keel bolts passing through reinforcements laminated directly to the hull are a construction method used on some small-series composite sailing yachts.

Advantages: structural rigidity and the ability to visually inspect the keel attachment points from inside the hull.

‍

Another method involves a composite keel structure with a lead ballast bulb bolted to its lower section. This construction method has been used on certain Amel yacht models.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

To simplify production, some large French boatbuilders adopted a one-piece structural grid incorporating longitudinal stringers and transverse floors, which is then bonded to the inside of the hull.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

The Structural Inner Grid and Keel Bolts of an Oceanis 50

The Oceanis 50 uses a structural inner grid that incorporates the keel attachment points. The keel bolts pass through this structural grid, which helps distribute loads into the hull. This construction method simplifies production but can restrict visual and physical access to parts of the keel attachment structure from inside the boat. Only the accessible ends of the keel bolts may be visible, while the space between the structural grid and the hull can remain concealed.

Corrosion can be a concern because water may accumulate in the bilge, particularly around concealed structural components.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

The mark left on Cheeki Rafiki's hull after the loss of its keel.

‍

Corrosion or deterioration of keel bolts, combined with structural damage or failure of the keel attachment system, can in extreme cases result in keel loss. In 2014, the Beneteau First 40.7 Cheeki Rafiki lost its keel in the North Atlantic and capsized, resulting in the loss of all four crew members. The investigation identified possible structural weakening from previous groundings and repairs, along with possible keel bolt deterioration.

Fin keels may use cast-iron or lead ballast to lower the boat's centre of gravity and increase its righting moment. Ballasted fin keels come in various configurations, including L-shaped and T-shaped keels, often featuring a bulb at the bottom of the fin.

‍

‍

Many modern monohull sailing yachts use externally bolted fin keels. High-performance keel designs often combine a high-strength steel fin with a lead ballast bulb. Lead's high density allows ballast weight to be concentrated lower down, increasing the righting moment.

‍

‍

‍

A steel keel fin combined with a lead ballast bulb on a 76-foot sailing yacht.

In 1978, Éric Tabarly experimented with depleted uranium ballast, a material considerably denser than lead, to concentrate weight as low as possible. The innovation sparked controversy at the time. Retractable fin keels, also known as lifting keels, are another type of keel configuration.

‍

Advantages of the fin keel:

  • Improved manoeuvrability under engine power
  • An optimised righting moment, improving the boat's ability to carry sail
  • Robust construction when the keel is properly integrated into the hull structure

‍

‍

Disadvantages:

  • Bolted-on keels require careful inspection and maintenance of their attachment points, particularly after grounding.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

3. Twin Keels: Ideal for Taking the Ground

‍

The RM 1370 in its twin-keel configuration.

As the name suggests, a twin-keel configuration consists of two keels positioned on either side of the boat's centreline. These keels allow the boat to remain upright when taking the ground on a suitable seabed. They are designed to provide stable support when taking the ground, without requiring additional shores or supports in suitable conditions.

‍
Twin-keel sailing yachts can be particularly robust, especially older Westerly models with encapsulated keels. They can take the ground without additional supports on suitable surfaces and may be stored ashore without a conventional keel cradle, provided they are adequately supported.

‍

‍

‍

However, older twin-keel designs often deliver poorer upwind performance than comparable fin-keel yachts. Modern twin-keel yachts, such as those built by Django and RM, offer significantly better sailing performance than many earlier designs. The twin keels on modern RM yachts can provide a draught approaching two metres, while Django twin-keel designs feature asymmetrical fins optimised for upwind performance, a considerable departure from the short keels found on older Westerly yachts.

‍

‍

The short twin keels of a Westerly Centaur.

Advantages:

  • Easy drying out and convenient winter storage
  • Robust construction

Disadvantages:

  • Generally poorer upwind performance than comparable fin-keel yachts, although this may be less important for some cruising sailors.

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

Inscrivez-vous à notre newsletter
Et restez informés des dernières actualités et bon plans d'Ocean Skills !
Read about our privacy policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.